Concert Review

YE Turned Footprint Center Into a Ritual of Eras, Controversy, and Catalog Hits

By Anthony CavaleShowMarch 10, 2024UpdatedSeptember 30, 2026

YE & Ty Dolla $ign · Vultures Listening Experience · Footprint Center · Phoenix, AZ

YE & Ty Dolla $ign performing during the Vultures Listening Experience at Footprint Center in Phoenix, AZ — concert photography by Anthony Cavale for Cavale Live
Photo: Anthony Cavale

A personal recap of YE's Vultures listening experience in Phoenix, capturing the controversy, spontaneous rollout, era-driven crowd, minimalist stage design, surprise family moments, and the power of a catalog that still filled an arena.

Love him, hate him, or feel indifferent about him, YE — the artist formerly known as Kanye West — is undeniably one of the most impactful artists of this generation.

He pushes the boundaries in every direction he's facing at the time, for better or for worse. After his highly criticized takes on the Jewish community, YE was on a mission, determined to show the world and the music industry that you can't cancel him. And in some ways, he did.

YE performed a handful of listening experiences for his new album Vultures 1 with Ty Dolla $ign. At the time, there wasn't a fully set-out schedule, which is pretty much expected with anything YE does. The announcements for these shows were spontaneous. One show he'd be in Italy, another he'd be in Japan, then suddenly, Phoenix, Arizona was next.

I remember exactly where I was. I was sitting in the doctor's office waiting for my annual checkup when my friend messaged me saying that YE was bringing his listening experience to Phoenix.

I froze.

I couldn't believe that out of all the places he had been traveling — New York, Chicago, Italy, Japan — next on his list was Phoenix. I immediately hopped on Vivid Seats to claim my spot for this experience, front and center, where I truly believed I had the perfect view.

When I showed up about an hour and a half early, there were already two separate lines that simultaneously wrapped around Footprint Center. I was curious to see what the turnout was going to look like. Despite the political backlash and social scrutiny he had recently faced, you wouldn't have known anything had happened to him.

Everyone was there.

And I mean eras.

Much like Taylor Swift, YE has his own eras. He is arguably one of the only rap artists with that kind of distinguished discography and visual evolution. People dressed up from every chapter — early 2000s pink polo and backpack College Dropout YE, the My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy elegance, the hardcore rebellious Yeezus era, all the way to the modern-day Vultures era.

I came dressed to the nines myself, choosing the Yeezus era as my inspiration. That version of YE always stood out to me — darker, more rebellious, more industrial, more raw. So walking into that arena dressed in that lane felt like I was stepping into one specific chapter of his world while everyone else was representing their own.

Young, old, and everything in between — this was truly a unique demographic of people that showed up. YE is one of those few artists who has that kind of range.

I remember standing there, making friends with the people near me, talking, waiting, and taking in the scene. In almost any other circumstance, I would be irritated having to wait two extra hours for a show to start. But for an artist like YE, as long as I got to see him perform, I honestly didn't care. I was just excited to be there.

And in true YE fashion, he showed up two hours after the announced start time.

"Earliest he's ever been," me and another spectator jokingly said.

But once the show started, it was absolutely worth the wait.

One thing about YE is that it's not just the music that's the experience. It's the set design. The stage design. The atmosphere.

The entire floor was completely cleared out. No seats. No standing-room crowd. No traditional stage packed with instruments or giant screens everywhere. Just an open white floor that felt empty, intentional, and almost sacred. Hovering above it was this massive circular cloth screen, almost like a 360-degree veil or halo hanging over the arena. It wrapped around the center space and caught the light in a way that made the whole thing feel heavenly, foggy, and unreal.

It didn't feel like a regular concert. It felt like walking into some kind of ritual space.

YE is notoriously known for having some of the most unique and innovative stage designs in music. Nothing is basic with this man. Everything is new, unusual, creative, different, and exciting. No matter how you feel about it, you feel something.

And then boom.

The lights went out.

The show started.

No warning. No countdown. No nothing.

Everything on his terms.

And just like it was advertised, it was a listening experience. YE, Ty Dolla $ign, and a surprise appearance from his kids took center stage and vibed out to the entire album. YE, Ty Dolla $ign, and North West performed with microphones in hand.

The visuals matched the darkness of the album. The masks, the smoke, the shadows, the heavy lighting, the blank white floor, and that giant cloth structure above them all made the whole thing feel eerie and cinematic. At times, they looked like silhouettes moving inside a dream. Other times, it felt like you were watching something through a lens, like the whole arena had been turned into one giant film frame.

Then, in one of the most unexpected moments of the night, YE went into the stands.

He didn't just stay isolated in the middle of the arena. He entered the crowd, surrounded by fans holding up their phones, and the energy completely shifted. Seeing him inside the audience like that made the entire place explode. It was chaotic, intimate, and surreal all at once — the kind of moment where everyone realizes they are witnessing something they're probably going to talk about for years.

But after the listening experience was over, something unique happened — something I had never seen before.

YE just started playing his catalog of hits.

Starting from the College Dropout era and moving all the way through his current discography, he played hit after hit after hit, ending, of course, with "Runaway."

The man didn't even have to sing.

He just stood center stage, jumped around, amplified the crowd, and watched as the entire arena sang his songs nearly word for word.

What other artist can sell out an entire arena, stand in the center, and watch the crowd erupt as he plays hit after hit after hit?

It was definitely an experience I won't ever forget.

Being a fan of his, I got everything I wanted and more. From the show itself, to the energy, to the crowd, to the history of his music being played in that arena, it felt bigger than just a concert.

My personal comments for YE are this: I recognize and have empathy for his mental illness, and I hope he gets the proper support and assistance he needs to heal from the pain he has felt and to fix the pain he is causing.

Concert ReviewYE & Ty Dolla $ign
Follow Anthony CavaleInstagram

AI Editorial Disclosure: The experiences, reporting, observations, ideas and voice in this story are Anthony Cavale’s. ChatGPT was used only as an editorial assistant to help organize, structure, copyedit and refine material originally developed by Cavale. All photography and final editorial decisions are his.

Photo Gallery · 20 Images